ST. LOUIS 鈥 A judge ruled Wednesday in favor of a north St. Louis nonprofit seeking to remove sewer bills from its property bought at a tax sale.
The ruling in favor of Tabernacle Community Development Corporation may clear the way for investors citywide to buy properties from the city鈥檚 land bank or at tax sales unencumbered by delinquent sewer bills, and help return some of the roughly 25,000 vacant, abandoned properties in St. Louis 鈥 about 10,000 of which are owned by a city agency 鈥 to productive use.
鈥淚 think it鈥檚 the right thing,鈥 Rev. Andre Alexander, Tabernacle鈥檚 president, said Wednesday outside the courtroom. 鈥淎nd I think it will be beneficial to our city as a whole.鈥
For decades, city and state lawmakers have struggled to deal with properties left behind as a half million people moved to the suburbs, passing laws trying to clear the way for redevelopment.
People are also reading…
Tax sales in the city are supposed to wipe clean a property鈥檚 title of any outstanding loans or tax liens.
Yet when treated unpaid sewer bills like unpaid tax bills, the Metropolitan St. Louis Sewer District adopted a more aggressive collection approach and stopped allowing the tax sales to clear its sewer bills, which are attached as liens to properties.
Those MSD bills sometimes climb into the thousands at homes and businesses where the owners walked away years prior. In distressed neighborhoods, that can mean the bills reach sums higher than the property value itself. The Post-Dispatch found many instances where MSD bills exceeded property values by thousands of dollars.
In 2022, vacant property advocates got the state legislature to amend the law in an attempt to clarify that MSD liens would be extinguished when the city sells land for unpaid taxes.
In October, Tabernacle sued the sewer district over property north of Fairground Park that the nonprofit purchased at a 2022 St. Louis tax sale.
MSD bills on the property were triple what it was worth, Tabernacle officials said.
But MSD argued the new state law conflicts with its charter, governed by the Missouri Constitution, and is therefore void.
The district says it鈥檚 a matter of fairness: By allowing its sewer bills to be cleared, as other taxes and mortgages are, it was asking its other customers to pay those bills.
鈥淎ll of our customers, including those that don鈥檛 reside in the city, would have to basically subsidize (tax) sales if we were to write those balances off or reduce the balances,鈥 MSD Finance Director Marion Gee said earlier this year.
In court Wednesday, Tabernacle鈥檚 lawyer, Michael Hickey of Lewis Rice, called MSD鈥檚 argument that it is exempt from the state law an 鈥渆xtreme position.鈥 The state constitution 鈥渄idn鈥檛 make MSD an entity that is insulated from any further regulation by the state.鈥
Allowing their argument to stand would 鈥渃hill鈥 investment in tax-sale and abandoned properties in St. Louis, Hickey said.
Jonathan Beck, representing MSD, countered that the sewer district has a surprising amount of power under the state constitution.
鈥淭he public policy arguments Mr. Hickey made, while persuasive and on point, are not relevant,鈥 Beck told the judge.
But Judge Jason Sengheiser was ready to rule immediately and granted Tabernacle鈥檚 motion for summary judgement, saying only that he didn鈥檛 see a conflict with the state statute and the constitution.
An attorney for MSD said the sewer district had not yet decided whether it would appeal.
Peter Hoffman, an attorney who focuses on vacant property issues at nonprofit Legal Services of Eastern Missouri, was watching the arguments Wednesday. There are already many hurdles for organizations like Tabernacle to buy and rehab abandoned properties in neglected neighborhoods, he said.
鈥淎t least in this case,鈥 Hoffman said, 鈥渢his is one less barrier.鈥